Shop Bars & DrinksBars & SnacksElectrolyte DrinksEnergy DrinksProtein Drinks SHOP ALL → Bundle & Save SHOP ALL → CBD SHOP ALL → Diet & EnergyBlood Sugar SupportThermogenicsWeight Management SHOP ALL → Essential Oils SHOP ALL → Fitness AccessoriesHeart Rate MonitorsTraining EquipmentWatch AccessoriesWatches SHOP ALL → Joints Support & OmegasFish OilJoints SupportPlant Based Omegas SHOP ALL → Lab Tests SHOP ALL → Men's HealthMen's Sexual HealthProstate SupportTestosterone Support SHOP ALL → On Sale ProductsFLASH SALEThis Week's Sale SHOP ALL → PerformanceAmino AcidsPerformancePre-WorkoutsRecovery SHOP ALL → Probiotics & DigestionCleanse & DetoxDigestion SupportProbiotics SHOP ALL → ProteinPlant Based ProteinWhey Protein SHOP ALL → Superfoods & Plant BasedGreens MixesSuperfoodsVegan Products SHOP ALL → Targeted HealthHeart HealthLiver HealthMemory & FocusStress & Sleep SHOP ALL → Training Programs SHOP ALL → Vitamins & MineralsB VitaminsImmunityMineralsMultivitamins SHOP ALL → Women's HealthBone HealthHair, Skin, & NailsHormone SupportWomen's Sexual Health SHOP ALL → LATEST PRODUCTS Fitness FitnessEssential Amino Acids Support Muscle Protein Synthesis FitnessMaximizing Recovery After Training & Competition FitnessThe Keto Diet Plan May Benefit Body Builders FitnessHigh Intensity Interval Exercise VS Moderate Intensity, Continuous Training Health & WellnessTop Five Tips to Avoid Training too Much FitnessVitamins and Minerals to Improve Adolescent Fitness Fitness Topics PerformanceRecovery Latest in Fitness Health & Wellness Health & WellnessNutritional Factors May Modify Risk to Covid-19 Health & WellnessCOVID-19: Vitamin D May Modulate Risk & Severity Health & WellnessFish Oil Lowers Cardiovascular Disease Risk Health & WellnessTeenagers Top Five Foods for Success Health & WellnessResearch Confirms Optimum Vitamin D Blood Values Vitamins & MineralsAre Multivitamins Right for You? Health & Wellness Topics Health & Wellness ProductsImmunityMen's HealthWomen's Health Latest in Health & Wellness Nutrition NutritionTop Five Foods to Fight Inflammation RecipesHigh Protein Blue Berry Pancakes NutritionThe Top Five Healthy Foods for Women High Protein RecipesEgg & Turkey Stuffed Peppers Low Carb RecipesHearty Breakfast Sausage NutritionAre Cleansing Supplements Right for You? Nutrition Topics Nutrition ProductsRecipesVitamins & MineralsWeight Management Latest in Nutrition WEB SERIES Maximum Wellness Workout Wednesday LATEST IN WEB SERIES Shop SHOP Bars & Drinks Bundle & Save CBD Diet & Energy Essential Oils Fitness Accessories Joints Support & Omegas Lab Tests Men's Health On Sale Products Performance Probiotics & Digestion Protein Superfoods & Plant Based Targeted Health Training Programs Vitamins & Minerals Women's Health LATEST PRODUCTS Fitness Fitness Topics Performance Recovery Fitness Essential Amino Acids Support Muscle Protein Synthesis Fitness Maximizing Recovery After Training & Competition Fitness The Keto Diet Plan May Benefit Body Builders Fitness High Intensity Interval Exercise VS Moderate Intensity, Continuous Training Health & Wellness Top Five Tips to Avoid Training too Much Fitness Vitamins and Minerals to Improve Adolescent Fitness Latest in Fitness Health & Wellness Health & Wellness Topics Health & Wellness Products Immunity Men's Health Women's Health Health & Wellness Nutritional Factors May Modify Risk to Covid-19 Health & Wellness COVID-19: Vitamin D May Modulate Risk & Severity Health & Wellness Fish Oil Lowers Cardiovascular Disease Risk Health & Wellness Teenagers Top Five Foods for Success Health & Wellness Research Confirms Optimum Vitamin D Blood Values Vitamins & Minerals Are Multivitamins Right for You? Latest in Health & Wellness Nutrition Nutrition Topics Nutrition Products Recipes Vitamins & Minerals Weight Management Nutrition Top Five Foods to Fight Inflammation Recipes High Protein Blue Berry Pancakes Nutrition The Top Five Healthy Foods for Women High Protein Recipes Egg & Turkey Stuffed Peppers Low Carb Recipes Hearty Breakfast Sausage Nutrition Are Cleansing Supplements Right for You? Latest in Nutrition WEB SERIES WEB SERIESpodcastsMaximum Wellness podcastsWorkout Wednesday LATEST IN WEB SERIES Maximum Wellness Maximum Wellness, Episode 73: Frequency, Intensity, and Time Spent Exercising Is Key to Weight Loss Success Date November 18, 2020 In 2005, with the publication of my book, The Fat Burning Bible (John Wiley & sons), I called for at least 300 minutes of weekly exercise to reduce excess scale weight and body fat. That’s in spite of current recommendations, which states that exercise programs should exceed 225 weekly minutes to induce clinically significant weight loss. Now, my recommendation has found merit with research –”Exercise for Weight Loss: Further Evaluating Energy Compensation with Exercise” – which appeared in the November 2020 issue of Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise. The University of Kentucky study authors suggest that it will take in excess of 300 minute per week of exercise to overcome the approximate 1000 calories per week compensatory response that accompanies exercise. “The lack of weight loss success with exercise is due to compensatory responses counteracting the negative energy balance created by exercise to maintain homeostasis, thereby alleviating the energy deficit required for weight loss.” Maintaining energy balance, note the researchers, “can be viewed, as an evolutionarily conserved mechanism in place to retain bodily energy stores and reproductive function, a useful survival strategy in times of famine.” Several reasons for the post-exercise compensation effect include an increased food intake stimulated by a need to have calories in to exceed calories expended, and hormone regulators – acylated ghrelin, peptide YY, insulin, leptin (after eating or fasting) – that regulate hunger. Of specific note, are ghrelin – the hunger hormone produced by cells of the gastrointestinal tract – specifically the stomach, which increases food intake (stomach growl) and leptin – a hormone secreted by fat cells and enterocytes in the small intestine that regulate energy balance and inhibits hunger. It appears that obese individuals can experience leptin resistance – a situation that makes them non-responsive to the fullness effect or satiety after food consumption. To back up their exercise duration recommendations, the study authors employed a three-arm, randomized, controlled trial among sedentary adults between the ages of 18 to 40 – with a body mass index of 25 (overweight) to 35 (obese) to assess how individuals compensate for energy expended during a 12-wk aerobic exercise intervention – explaining the potential mechanisms and the role exercise dose plays in the compensatory response. The 44 final study participants (32 women) were assessed, after a medical history, physical, and diet and exercise history, along with other relevant tests – as to their rate of exercise energy expenditure, which was calculated from a graded exercise test averaged across five heart rate (HR) zones – zone 1, 50-59% of heart rate reserve (HRR), zone 2, 60-69%, zone 3, 70-79%, zone 4, 80-89% and zone 5, 90% or greater. The heart rate zones were calculated – based on the Karvonen formula, (220-age) – resting heart rate (RHR) x a high and low zone percent + resting heart rate. The energy compensation effect was calculated, as the difference between expected weight loss (based on exercise energy expenditure) and changes in fat and fat-free mass (DXA Scan). Resting energy expenditure (REE) was assessed via indirect calorimetry, while concentrations of acylated ghrelin, leptin, insulin, and glucagon-like peptide 1 (GLP-1) were assessed fasting and postprandial (six timepoints over 2 hours.) The exercise program consisted of a control group, who were asked to stay sedentary, while being offered exercise intervention, after the 12-week post-testing period; a 2-day per week exercise group, who performed exercise sessions between 90 to 120 minutes at a self-selected intensity (at minimum in HR zone 1); and a 6-day per week group, who trained between 40 to 60 minutes per session – with the same intensity qualifications, as the 2-day group. All participants used the Polar A-300 HR monitor and the Polar Flow software, allowing for monitoring and compliance – which had to be 90% to stay in the study over the 12-week intervention. The study, “demonstrates individuals do not increase their energy compensation with greater doses of exercise. This lack of significant compensation was observed as neither CI (energy compensation proportional to energy expended) or total energy compensated differed between groups. Rather, the greater dose of the 6-day per week group was needed to produce appreciable fat loss with exercise.” Additionally, “reductions in postprandial (after meal) leptin concentrations influence energy compensation, when controlling for all relevant exercise dose variables. This supports what has only recently been observed in rodents, that reducing leptin concentrations can restore leptin sensitivity in hypothalamic neurons and reduce food intake.” It also appears that, “reductions in postprandial ghrelin concentrations are an important predictor of body fat loss, regardless of exercise dose.” In short, more frequent exercise equaling 300 minute per week in HR zones 3 to 5 may account for a more favorable scale weight and fat loss in light of the exercise compensation effect.